The Triad Tipster - Spring 2005

Information for you and your career...

The Reality of Counter Offers

With the economy improving, many people are starting to look for better career opportunities.  Motivation for leaving a position usually comes down to one or more of these factors: location, money, work environment, job responsibilities. 

Depending on the situation, the employee giving notice may be met with a counteroffer aimed at enticing him/her to stay.  The counteroffer may be purely monetary, or it may address one or more of the other factors listed above.  As many people naturally resist change (and changing jobs is a huge decision), accepting a counteroffer that resolves one’s initial reasons for wanting to leave may seem like the perfect solution.   

However, here are some facts about counteroffers that may reduce their appeal: 

·         80% of those who accept a counteroffer leave or are terminated within a year.

·         Even if an employee accepts a counteroffer, his/her loyalty is always going to be in question.  The trust is broken between employer and employee.

·         The counteroffer could be a stopgap measure on the part of the employer until a replacement can be found for the employee (now that it is clear that he/she isn’t happy).

·         The extra money in the counteroffer is oftentimes the employee’s next raise, or even the next two raises.  Accepting the counteroffer could limit future earnings. 

Despite all this, in some situations accepting a counteroffer can be beneficial, especially if the relationship is a good one and the needs of both parties can be met.  Accommodations such as changing the physical space to allow for more efficient work, telecommuting, flexible hours, more/less responsibility...all can be good reasons for reconsidering a decision to leave a company.  Of course, such possibilities should have been discussed before the employee decided to leave. 

One last point to remember:  Money alone is never a good reason either to leave a position that is otherwise satisfying or to accept a counteroffer.  Employees being presented with a counteroffer should ask themselves, “If I was worth $40,000 prior to giving notice, why is the employer willing to pay more for me today?”  Also, “Will I have to threaten to quit in the future to get what I feel I deserve?”.

Have you looked at your resume lately? (part ten)   


Throughout this series, we have discussed information that should (and shouldn’t!) be included on a resume, as well as the formatting that works best when working with agencies.  First impressions are very important, so here are a few more pointers on resume presentation: 

·         When emailing, in the message body state where you saw the advertisement.  If there is a job number from an internet posting...include it! 

·         A cover letter shouldn’t be another resume.  Make a couple of quick points as to why you feel you fit this position.  Refer back to your resume, “As you will see, when I worked at XYZ, I had many of the same responsibilities listed in your ad”.

·         If you are relocating closer to the company’s location, make sure you state that in the cover letter.  

·         A resume isn’t a novel, but it shouldn’t be too general either.  If you can fill two or even three pages with solid information, that’s fine.  If, on the other-hand, your two or three page resume is rambling and filled with ‘fluff’, you should strive to be more concise.

·         When dealing with agencies, have one comprehensive resume that covers all your skills.  Tailoring a resume for one type of job will limit the opportunities for which the agency will call you.

·         Check and re-check your resume for completeness and grammar, read it again in a day or two, and use spell check!

·         Honest and consistent information is critical.  Agencies keep records of past resumes and take note when updated resumes aren’t consistent with prior ones.   

Next time: Accents and additions to set it apart...